Macaroni Kid
St. Mary's
Macaroni Kid   Editions

Cell Phones in School


What's Your Call?

top image
As technology develops, social media creeps into our lives and debates are formed.  Students and parents alike have been protesting the ban of cell phones in schools.  There is no doubt about the fact that cell phones in school are a problem and that kids are using them so much that the majority can't imagine living without them.  But in school?  There are definitely pros and cons to this debate. 

Cons

1.  They are a distraction.  Kids like to text and do not always turn their phones off in class.

2.  Children can use them to cheat during tests by sharing information and/or storing it on their phones.

3.  Camera phones are widely popular and have been known to be used inappropriately in school, for example in the bathrooms.

4.  Bullies use texting as a form of harassment.

5.  Phones are very easy to steal.  And with many costing $100+, they are very expensive to replace.

Pros

1.  Being able to reach your child at any time, gives the parent/caregiver a feeling of security.

2.  Communication made easy.  With working parents more hours and children with busy schedules, cell phones make it easy to stay in touch.  Cell phones allow kids to call the away parent and share their joy after blocking that goal or finishing the last chapter of their "new" favorite book.

3.  After school activities, practices and meetings always don't always end on schedule.  A cell phone enables your child to call for transportation when they are ready; this means no sitting in the parking lot waiting.

But here's the BIG QUESTION ... Does your child really NEED a cell phone?  Or are you falling prey into the "she's got one, I want one too" trap.  And who pays for the airtime?  Every family is different, and ultimately it's your call:  to phone or not to phone.  But it is also your responsibility as a parent to teach and enforce household and school rules regarding responsible cell phone ownership and use.

What do you think about cell phones in school or kids and phones?  We want to know; leave your comment below.


Comments

1) Starla Rudley said:
First rules must be set on the usage of the phone. We gave our 10 year old her first phone and she is very responsible with hers. She carries it with her at all times, when she is at school she is to keep on vibrate and not to use it unless it is an emergency. She not allowed to text until she gets home. And we monitor who she has given her number out to. I know when she gets older this may be harder to do, but with the rules in place it has worked so far. If her grades lack or chores are not completed she may lose her phone. So far so good.
1 year, 10 months ago

Have your say


Sign Up For The FREE Macaroni Kid Newsletter

Macaroni Kid delivers weekly tips on the best local events for kids and families in your community!